“Suffering” and the Artist’s Identity: A Dichotomy of Key Inspiration and Detrimental Internalization

By Jane Warren

Make it look easy, no matter how much it hurts.

Ballet is notoriously centered in suffering: dancers willingly endure physical pain for the sake of their art, pushing their bodies and minds beyond the point of breakage. Underlying the beauty and supposed ease of ballet is a culture where the most tortured artists are lauded as having the highest aesthetic and artistic excellence. Growing up in the ballet studio, my idols were emaciated bodies whose glory was derived from the amount of physical and psychological torment they could tolerate. The glorification of the suffering artist in ballet, and the conflation of the identity of being an artist with the self-imposition of torturous conditions, is equally present in other creative fields. The “tortured artist” is taken to be the most fascinating sort of creative, whose skill in expression comes from their inner madness and turmoil. “Suffering” in ballet specifically refers to the mental illnesses, trauma, and physical pain experienced by dancers. In the general art world, this same principle applies, with “suffering” more broadly referring to disabilities in the form of physical incapacitation or pain, mental illness, and psychological trauma. Where, then, is the balance between the necessity of expressing the invariable experience of struggle in art, and the point where undergoing suffering for the sake of art becomes detrimental to the artist? When has my own suffering gone too far?

The mythologization of tortured artists enforces the notion that suffering— and the exacerbation thereof— is necessary in order to produce the most valuable and well-recieved art; suffering is viewed by many artists as the source of their creative abilities. On the societal level, artists are simultaneously praised for the work their suffering produces and dismissed from receiving proper treatment for their mental struggles. In other words, the “tortured artist” trope entraps artists in their illnesses and leads them to exacerbate their own suffering for the sake of art. The proliferation of glorified suffering in the art world distorts society’s view on what constitutes valuable art, and simultaneously projects harmful ideals and expectations onto the artists who create it. In other words, the adoption of suffering as a tool to quantify creative value is consequential both for art itself and for those who identify as creatives. While suffering is a valuable source of artistic inspiration and an unavoidable human experience, the societal glamorization of the tortured artist wrongfully equates suffering with creativity and enforces the notion that it leads to the creation of more meaningful art— relegating artists to a seemingly inescapable state of turmoil. I myself have been in this state before; I escaped. The suffering was never worth it.

The inner workings of the suffering artist’s mind are poignantly highlighted in Shoshana Kessock’s essay Falling/Burning, where the author recounts her drastic highs and lows while suffering from untreated bipolar disorder. Kessock’s “suffering,” specifically, was her mental illness and the incapacitation it caused her in the form of manic and depressive episodes. During Kessock’s manic episodes of “flying,” a rapid flow of creative ideas erupted from within her: an energy, or “spark,” which she believed to be the source of her artistic brilliance (180). These chaotic highs in her mental illness were supposedly what made her great; her illness became inseparable from her identity as an artist (and thus a central element of her self-image), for it brought about a seemingly infinite wellspring of creativity. Kessock points to the paradoxical treatment of mentally ill artists by the general population: while their madness is viewed as a fantastical source of brilliance, they are simultaneously marginalized as a result of their illness, enduring great suffering under the immense pressure to “feel for their art” (181). The artists are concurrently romanticized and stigmatized under this harmful rhetoric, with their illness becoming both a point of praise and admiration as the root of their art’s value, and also a scathing marker of otherness. When illness becomes analogous with creativity, artists hesitate to seek treatment for their mental struggles. Not wanting to lose the spark inside them to dulling medications or therapy, they avoid the alleged killing of their art by refusing treatment altogether and thus drive themselves further into states of suffering and chaos. Suffering becomes inextricable from their identities due to their characterization by society as fitting the “tortured artist” stereotype. Artists, then, internalize the idea that they cannot create art without undergoing deep, even hyperbolic, suffering. More than this, though, the artist comes to believe (as I once did) that their suffering is precisely what makes them exceptional.

Despite decades of exploratory study surrounding the occurrence of various mental illnesses in artists and the theoretical relationship between “madness” and artistic ability, it has not been definitively established whether mental illness brings about greater creativity within artists (Armitage). Since the days of Plato, who claimed that “divine madness” was the origin of poets’ creativity (Johnson 5), the connection between mental illness and creativity has been a point of societal and academic speculation. As an intangible and subjective characteristic, though, creativity arguably cannot be properly quantified at all— nor can it be traced to a singular source. However, a 2014 study published in the European Journal of Social Psychology identified a correlation between viewers’ valuation of art and their perception of the artist’s madness. In line with the glamorization of the stereotypical tortured artist, this study demonstrated that artworks were received more positively, or given higher value, when participants were informed that the artist suffered from mental illness. In other words, works created by artists whose behavior was more eccentric— more abnormal, more other— were judged as inherently more meaningful works of “creative genius” (Igou and van Tilburg). This minuscule instance reflects the broader societal mythologization of the most psychologically tortured artists as being the most skilled and accomplished. Suffering is designated as a prerequisite to artists’ success and a determining factor in how well one’s art is received by the public. Thus, it is collectively perceived as an essential element of the creative process, especially if one wants to create “good art.” Meanwhile, there is no empirical basis for whether suffering genuinely gives these artists more creative merit. Creativity does not exist in absolutes, and should not be distilled down to the plane of objective experimentation. The entertainment of the idea that the most profound creativity is derived from struggle in credible academic settings gives validity to artists’ twisted internalization of their mental illness as their purest creative resource; it enforces the conflation of their artistic identity with a lifetime of agony.

In the ballet world, perhaps more than in any other artistic discipline, “suffering” for the sake of one’s art is a marker of greatness and peak dedication. Physical and psychological pain are integral to the experience of being a dancer, to the extent that enduring suffering or incapacitation garners immediate admiration and respect. In an exemplification of “[loving] his art form more than he cared for his own health,” star ballet dancer Rudolf Nureyev concealed his AIDS diagnosis and its accompanying symptoms during the late years of his performing career (Abou-Jaoude). When his diagnosis and the suffering he endured as a result of his illness came to light after his death, “his command of technique became less important than the inner fortitude he showed in continuing to contribute to the ballet” for audiences (Abou-Jaoude). Nureyev was praised for his neglect of his disability, which amplified the notability of his work in the eyes of his fans. Meanwhile, Vaslav Nijinsky, an esteemed dancer and choreographer whose schizophrenia caused his eventual institutionalization and departure from the stage, was praised by audiences as a mad, perfection-crazed artist whose eccentricity cemented his greatness. His glory was predicated on his mental illness. In both Nureyev and Nijinsky’s cases, immense “suffering” was not only suppressed by the dancers themselves, but was romanticized by audiences. These men’s disabilities, and their ability to perform despite them, caused them to be dignified as figures of legend: tortured luminaries whose struggles amplified their brilliance as artists. Their identification with suffering as inextricable from their artistic careers was enforced by the public’s fascination with their struggles.

During my time as a pre-professional ballet dancer, I often twistedly relished in my suffering. I was indoctrinated to believe that it was analogous with strength and success; after all, the most tortured dancers were generally exalted as having the most meaningful careers. The suffering I endured, both pertaining to physical injury and mental illness, was required for excellence; I meant nothing without it. My hunger for unachievable perfection drove the crazed decline of my mental and physical health, causing my turmoil to be internalized. Warned against allowing audiences to see the effort I put into my dancing, I had accepted my pain as a natural part of my existence, and even something that made me greater. All the while, the tangible signs of my ballet-exacerbated mental and physical distress— my underfed and deteriorating body, my numerous stress injuries, my immense, chronic exhaustion— were praised and affirmed by my studio’s artistic leadership and my peers as markers of discipline and fortitude.

In an artistic sphere where perfection is demanded, self-inflicted suffering is nearly intrinsic to the dancer’s lifestyle. Ballerinas sacrifice their mental and physical health in order to meet unbelievably high standards of performance within a culture where expressing even a hint of pain or turmoil is equated with weakness and failure. My peers and I engaged in an unspoken competition to see who could best conceal the grueling pain of pointe shoes and exhausted bodies with a demeanor of elegance— all while eating the least. Under immense pressure to fit a distorted standard of physical beauty and achieve unrealistic athletic feats, the occurrence of injury in dancers is amplified by the coincidence of eating disorders and excessive hours of strenuous exertion (Nir). Meanwhile, teachers encourage students to “walk it off,” dismissing their pain as mere imagination. The doctrine that perfection and composure are synonymous with balletic success leads dancers to repress any sign of struggle, accepting their pain as integral to their identity as an artist. Existing as a ballerina, then, is marked by suffering in silence, and  adhering firmly to the idea that enduring pain results in greater success and glory.

Is there any situation where suffering is genuinely beneficial to art and creativity? Art gains its value in its capacity to reflect genuine human experience and evoke an emotional response in the viewer due to the relatable emotions or phenomena it portrays. Suffering is irremovable from the human experience, and thus needs to be expressed in art as a part of the processing and healing of trauma and pain— both for the artists themselves and for consumers of art. The entire spectrum of what it means to be human could not possibly be authentically represented in art if there were no suffering artists; pain will inevitably be experienced, and necessitates creative expression. Undoubtedly, suffering is a valuable source of inspiration for countless artworks, from Edvard Munch’s The Scream to Van Gogh’s Self Portrait With Cut Ear; such cathartic expressions of struggle and distress were directly inspired by the artists’ experience with mental illness. Suffering is structurally integral to ballet as an art form which pushes humans beyond their natural limit, and has been the basis of many deeply profound choreographic works: where would the depth of the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet or the madness in Giselle originate, if not the painful parts of human existence?

Whether an artist’s suffering brings more meaning to a piece of art, or is the defining factor of an artwork’s worth, is less clear. Positive experiences, too, can inspire equally meaningful pieces of art which encapsulate a different side of the emotional spectrum; it is the juxtaposing existence of suffering that gives our joyful experiences so much meaning. While each piece of art is reflective of its creator, its significance is utterly subjective. Regardless of an artist’s intention, each work will be received uniquely by those who view it. Consequently, the suffering an artist has endured for their craft may go entirely unseen depending on how it is interpreted by each onlooker. Namely: ballet is perceived by audiences as simple and effortless, with the strain endured by dancers going unnoticed under their facade of elegant ease and grace. Quantifying the meaning of art, then, is fruitless: its significance is completely variable based on the beholder. There is no doubt that suffering is a fundamental source of creative inspiration. Art is meant to depict pain and vulnerability, and authentically reflects the human experience in doing so. As humans, we yearn to relate to art; seeing our experiences reflected in a creative work is key to confronting and comprehending our emotions. Consuming art which mirrors our feelings elicits an incredibly pure form of validation and mutuality. To completely remove suffering from the art world would be not only inauthentic, but directly contradictory to the purpose art plays in society as an expressive and interconnective tool. However, in no way is suffering a precondition for artistic excellence. Arguably, suffering does not make one extraordinary at all.

Suffering is, and always will be, a genesis for creativity as an ineluctable human occurrence. Where the “tortured artist” trope becomes deeply problematic, though, is when artists begin amplifying their suffering under the societally-imposed illusion that it will make them more influential, meaningful, or successful artists. The myth that mental illness produces creativity is baseless, and merely serves to entrap artists within their agony. Society’s glamorization of this tortured existence leads artists’ identities to be consumed by their madness, deepening their state of torture and (in some cases, fatally) resisting treatment for their afflictions under a belief that their artistic value will expire if they begin to heal. I was only able to begin recovering from my personal suffering after coming to terms with the fact that enduring mental and physical pain, unequivocally, did not make me a better or more worthy dancer— or human. I had never deserved to be in that much pain, nor to devalue myself so immensely.

A balance does exist when it comes to art and suffering: artists can depict their suffering without voluntarily worsening their mental state or internalizing their struggles as essential to the creative process. Struggle does not amplify success, nor is it a necessary sacrifice in the name of art, as I’ve come to realize after my departure from the professional ballet world. I am stronger for working to resolve my “suffering,” and can perform at a greater capacity when I dance on my own terms: absorbing and enjoying ballet as a form of personal expression, which I don’t have to suffer for the sake of. Dancing, after all, is far more gratifying and liberating when it does not cause you bodily pain. Arguably, the artist who overcomes their suffering and continues to produce fantastic art is better off than one who remains trapped by their struggles. Healing one’s suffering brings a completely new dynamism to art; it can be more fully appreciated and enjoyed when one is not exacting pain upon themselves to produce it, and realizes that their struggle is not definitive of their artistic (or human) identity. Suffering, in the end, is not related at all to exceptionalism or human worth. Each artist is inherently capable of expressing profound and complex beauty in their work, sourced from their own unique inner self. As an artist, what one should be creating is art which authentically represents human experiences— not creating more suffering.

Works Cited

Abou-Jaoude, Amir. “Hidden Struggle: Flaws in Ballet’s Disability Narrative.” The Stanford Daily, May 2019, stanforddaily.com/2019/05/17/hidden-struggle-flaws-in-ballets-disability-narrative/. Accessed 20 Mar. 2023.

Armitage, Calum. “Van Gogh and Romanticizing the Tortured Artist.” Postscript Magazine, Apr. 2019, postscriptmagazine.org/content/2019/03/04/van-gogh-and-romanticizing-the-tortured-artist. Accessed 20 Mar. 2023.

Johnson, Hayley Anne. Madness and the Muse: Understanding the Link between Creativity and Mental Illness. May 2014, conservancy.umn.edu/bitstream/handle/11299/163481/Johnson%2cHayley_ACL_Final_Project_Paper.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y. Accessed 20 Mar. 2023.

Kaufman, James C., and Paul J. Silvia. “Creativity and Mental Illness.” The Cambridge Handbook of Creativity, edited by James C. Kaufman and Robert J. Sternberg, vol. 6, no. 1, Cambridge University Press, 2010, pp. 381–94, 13.87.204.143/xmlui/bitstream/handle/123456789/7281/The%20Cambridge%20Handbook%20of%20Creativity.pdf?sequence=1#page=389. Accessed 20 Mar. 2023.

Kennedy, Al. “Why I Hate the Myth of the Suffering Artist.” The Guardian, 2 Apr. 2012, www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2012/apr/02/myth-of-the-suffering-artist. Accessed 20 Mar. 2023.

Nir, Sarah Maslin. “To Some Dancers, ‘Black Swan’ Is a Cautionary Tale.” The New York Times, 7 Jan. 2011, www.nytimes.com/2011/01/09/fashion/09swan.html. Accessed 20 Mar. 2023.

Van Tilburg, Wijnand Adriaan Pieter, and Eric Raymond Igou. “From van Gogh to Lady Gaga: Artist Eccentricity Increases Perceived Artistic Skill and Art Appreciation.” European Journal of Social Psychology, vol. 44, no. 2, Jan. 2014, pp. 93–103, https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.1999. Wiley Online Library. Accessed 20 Mar. 2023.

css.php